Trailer residents sue RV manufacturers over formaldehyde levels  Environment  <  Roaming Times Roaming Times - RV, motorhome, fifth wheel, travel trailer, RVing

Danger formaldehyde

MORE THAN 500 TRAILER RESIDENTS SUE RV MANUFACTURERS

NEW ORLEANS, Aug. 8 /PRNewswire/ -- Mobile home and travel trailer manufacturers allegedly exposed displaced victims of Hurricanes Katrina and Rita to harmful levels of formaldehyde, according to a lawsuit filed by more than 500 Louisianans who have resided in the federally provided housing units.

Filed late Tuesday in New Orleans federal court, the lawsuit alleges that the manufacturers violated federal and Louisiana laws by producing hurricane relief housing units that emit formaldehyde "at a dangerously unhealthy rate."

The plaintiffs reside or have resided in manufactured mobile homes and travel trailers that were provided by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) after the landfalls of the hurricanes in August and September 2005.

According to the Complaint, the housing units, ordered by the tens of thousands by the federal government, were manufactured "without the benefits of Defendants' usual quality control. Defendants were unable to find enough construction materials from their usual suppliers of low-formaldehyde emitting material, and, instead used high-formaldehyde emitting particle board, composite woods, adhesive and other materials in the manufacture of the Housing Units."

Attorneys Tony Buzbee and Peter K. Taaffe, of The Buzbee Law Firm, of Galveston, Texas, and John Munoz, of Garner & Munoz, of New Orleans, represent the plaintiffs.

Mr. Buzbee stated, "We allege that the defendants' rush to manufacture the housing units led them to produce and deliver unsafe and hazardous units. Our clients report a wide range of symptoms that are consistent with formaldehyde exposure. This troubling situation has compounded the misery of many who were displaced by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita."

The defendants are Gulf Stream Coach, Inc.; Fleetwood Enterprises, Inc.; Jayco Enterprises, Inc.; Starcraft RV, Inc.; Forest River, Inc.; Thor Industries, Inc.; Coachmen Industries, Inc.; Palomino RV; Pilgrim International, Inc.; Keystone Industries, Inc.; Morgan Building Systems, Inc.; Frontier RV, Inc.; Recreation by Design, LLC; and Skyline Corp.

The case is "Jerome Anthony Culler, et al., v. Gulf Stream Coach, Inc., et al." (Civil Action No. 07-4018) in the U.S. District Court of the Eastern District of Louisiana. The lawsuit will not be pursued as a class action, according to counsel.

What do you think? ...
Add your comments

Readers' comments:
Latest first

beachbum :   Does anyone have a list of either the worst brands or brands that are formaldehyde free?

Susan Rappoport :   My brother bought a new travel trailer when he retired at age 54. He planned to live in it and travel to different parts of the country. After a short time, he started getting sick. He had slurred speech, loss of balance, severe depression and other symptoms. One side of his back started hurting. When we finally got him to go to the doctor, he had Stage IV kidney cancer. He died from it. I tested his trailer for formaldehyde over a year and half after he bought it. He had been airing it out all fall and into the winter. He was out of the trailer. My sister and I were taking care of him. The formaldehyde level in the trailer tested at .265 parts per million. A professional embalmer is exposed to .3 parts per million and is required to wear safety gear when using formaldehyde. He was my little brother. He worked so hard all his life. He was such a good person. My faith has been severely tested watching the pain and sickness he had to go through. The manufacturers of these trailers are not made to follow the law regarding the so-called "safe" level of formaldehyde, which I believe is .1 parts per million. There are those who think .1 parts per million is way too high for health safety. He died two years ago. I did extensive internet searches on formaldehyde. Today is the first time I have been able to get back on the internet and look up formaldehyde poisoning. My brother left three sisters and two sons broken hearted.

ALLEN FRALEY :   I WAS POISONED BECAUSE MY CHEMCLEAN BOTTLE BY THETFORD RUPTURED AND RELEASED THE LIQID THROUGH OUT THE MOTOR HOME. EVIDENTLY THE BOTLE GOT TO HOT EVEN THOUGH THE AIR WAS ON. WE RETURNED IN THREE WEEKS OPENED THE DOOR, AND THE REST WAS HISTORY. I WAS BLEEDING FROM THE LUNGS ETC. HAD TO QUIT MY JOB AS DID MY WIFE. THE BOOTLE RUPTURED IN TWO LIKE SLITS AT THE BOTTOM AND THETFORD IS SAYING IT IS A CUT NOT A RUPTURE? ALL I KNOW IS I CAN HARDLY BREATH AFTER ALMOST A YEAR. AND SHARE MOST OF THE SYMTOMS OF THE OTHERS. HOW CAN WE TEST THAT BOTTLE?

Minnesota :   I think I had formaldehyde poisoning in the 1980s from my new home. It was not diagnosed at the time, I came to suspect it later after reading a newspaper article on the subject. My symptoms were: splitting headache for one year, insomnia, tired in daytime, severe short-term memory loss, burning esophagus, trouble inhaling deeply, trouble swallowing, pounding heart, depression, aching muscles, trouble making simple decisions and extreme muscle weakness. The memory loss was such that when driving I would forget the difference between red and green traffic lights. When going to the mailbox or downstairs to the freezer, I would have to talk aloud continually, telling myself where I was going, otherwise, I would forget before I got there. I could not enjoy a television show because my bad memory would not allow me to follow the plot. When reading a book (and I read every book I could find on depression), I would have to re-read each paragraph 5-10 times before it would sink into my memory. The headache was so bad that I would tip-toe around the house, because any jostling at all increased the pain of the pounding headache. The breathing problems were so bad that I was afraid to go to sleep at night, fearing that I would suffocate because it was such an effort to breathe. It was so hard to swallow that I would carry a napkin around to spit in rather than subject myself to needless swallowing.

namsangels :   Did anyone have memory loss, eye color change, muscle pain?

  
Add your comments
  

Latest RoTi articles about the environment and RVing :
Why don't we want the diesel?
More than half of ALL cars sold in Europe are diesel...diesel engines have never really been popular for passenger cars in the USA - why?
Downsizing from a class A motorhome to a class B?
Words of wisdom from Roaming Times' readers - downsizing, fulltiming in a class B?, saving fuel & helping the environment, Roadtrek dominates market share...
Teardrop trailers
Streamlined, light weight, easy to tow, good for the environment, retro RVs - we review popular teardrop trailers with links...
'Green' park models - Cavco anticipates demand
Featuring recycled materials, low VOC paints, water and energy efficient appliances and fixtures, insulated windows and enough solar panels to make the units energy independent
New "green RV" at Florida RV supershow
"At first glance, it may seem RVing is hard on the environment - It's not"...
Why don't we want the diesel engine?
More than half of ALL cars sold in Europe are diesel - why not the US?
"Clean diesel" vehicles
The Audi clean diesel averages 46 mpg on mileage marathon - we need more of these technolgies applied to RVs!
Reducing formaldehyde in RVs
A wool "safety blanket" to clean up the contaminated air that occurs in RVs when formaldehyde is released
[1/7]

See also: Roaming Times Green Pages - RVing and the environement

    


RV manufacturers (open in new window):



Copyright 1999-2008 Roaming Times.  All rights reserved. Contact us. Terms of service.  Site Map.  About Us.  Corporate address: Roaming Times, 4575 E Bajada Rd., Cave Creek, AZ 85331

Roaming Times has thousands of pages of information - search the site with Google:

Google
www Roaming Times

 

 

Consumer Reports